Skip to main content
Long Island Today

That story moved on.

The link may be off. Browse today’s feed.

All good news →

Community · Greater Long Island

Off-season escape: A night at the 98-year-old Montauk Yacht Club

By Greater Long Island November 18, 2026 2 min read

The historic Star Island resort, built by the man who made Miami Beach, gets quiet and romantic once the summer crowds clear out

A chilled bottle of champagne. A pocket-size sandy beach right outside the patio door. A toilet paper roll creatively folded into a tiny sailboat.

That’s how the Montauk Yacht Club welcomes you, and it sets the tone for a stay that’s all about small, thoughtful touches.

Greater Long Island spent a night at the historic Star Island resort this month. The summer crowds were long gone, and Montauk had slowed to a nice, off-season pace. If you’ve written off the East End until Memorial Day, the Montauk Yacht Club is happy to prove you wrong.

The Montauk Yacht Club has stood on Star Island since 1928, when developer Carl Fisher opened it as part of his grand plan to turn Montauk into the “Miami Beach of the North.” Fisher had already converted a Florida swamp into Miami Beach.

In 1927, he used dynamite to cut a channel between Lake Montauk, then a freshwater lake, and Block Island Sound, turning the lake into a harbor for the yachts of his wealthy pals.