Skip to main content
Long Island Today

That story moved on.

The link may be off. Browse today’s feed.

All good news →

Schools · Dan's Papers

Ana Gasteyer Brings ‘Sugar & Booze’ Holiday Show to Riverhead

By Dan's Papers November 17, 2026 2 min read

Iconic Saturday Night Live cast member (1996-2002) and Broadway star Ana Gasteyer, famous for her impressions of Martha Stewart and characters such as Bobbie Moughan-Culp (middle-school music teacher) and NPR radio host Margaret Jo, among many others, is coming to The Suffolk in Riverhead (118 East Main Street) with an unforgettable holiday music show on Saturday, December 5 at 8 p.m. Ana Gasteyer s Sugar & Booze Holiday Spectacular features classic Christmas songs and originals from her retro-inspired Sugar & Booze album, which shows off her brilliant singing voice and has been hailed as “an uproarious homage to Christmas albums of old” by Billboard.

Gasteyer recently spoke with Dan’s Papers about the show and what fans can expect if they join her for the festive fun in Riverhead. Tickets and info are available at thesuffolk.org.

The show is a collection of seasonal favorites, it’s a big holiday party. We’ve got a full horn section. It’s a musical evening that’s celebrating the season, basically. We have a bunch of reimagined classics, music from the canon. We have some holiday originals and we just we have a good time.

Do you feel like you got a chance to show your singing chops much with Saturday Night Live?

In my opinion, at the time I did, but at that time people didn’t think of me as a singer. It was pre-social media, so many things kind of live in their own lanes from that generation. I was a voice major at Northwestern University. I went to Chicago, started doing comedy, dropped out of music school, found improv, and when you do comedy, you use whatever’s in your toolbox. So I sang a lot, and then I started doing Broadway shows because I was in New York and I loved theater. And then as I started to do music on my own, make work with my own band. It was just a natural fit, this kind of American standards throwback jazz, because I like working with an ensemble, I like improvisation. It was just a great place to marry wit and lyrics, and musicianship, basically.

I love the holidays, and so much of my personal work canon has existed around the holidays. Obviously, Schweddy Balls from SNL, Martha Stewart, and then I wrote a Christmas movie with my friend Rachel Dratch a couple years ago. A lot of things do come together for me around the season, and I love performing around the holidays. I think that people look for opportunities to celebrate together, and my show is one of those nights. Like, it’s become a tradition in a lot of places that I go. It’s maybe my first time in Riverhead, but in the Midwest, I tend to tour once a year, we get crowds year after year after year. It’s kind of like an annual tradition. It’s so much fun. People wear their holiday sweaters and their ridiculous outfits, and we try to reward all seasonal haberdashery.