Best Ice Cream on Long Island.

1. 1
   Gelateria Dei Coltelli

   Williston Park · ★ 4.7
2. 2
   Ice Cream Cottage

   Mastic · ★ 4.6
3. 3
   Mia's Ice Cream Kitchen

   Centereach · ★ 4.7
4. 4
   Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen & Space

   St James · ★ 4.8
5. 5
   Ralph's Italian Ices

   Farmingville · ★ 4.7
6. 6
   Paradise Ice Cream

   Mastic Beach · ★ 4.8
7. 7
   Manny's Sweet Treats

   Mineola · ★ 4.1
8. 8
   Ralph's Italian Ices

   Patchogue · ★ 4.3
9. 9
   Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

   Garden City · ★ 4.6
10. 10
    Roger's Dessert Bar

    Patchogue · ★ 4.9

Our editors' #1 pick for the best ice cream on Long Island is Gelateria Dei Coltelli (Williston Park — ★ 4.7). See the full ranked top 10 on this page.